This page contains materials intended
to facilitate class discussion (excerpts from readings,
outlines of issues, links to resources, etc.). The
materials are not necessarily the same as the instructor's
teaching notes and are not designed to represent
a full exposition or argument. This page is subject
to revision as the instructor finalizes preparation.
(Last revised
2/12/02
)
Condition I Business is now the universal
institution (or, business = life)
Peter Drucker,
Post-Capitalist Society (1993):
"Most people
when they hear the word "management" still
hear 'business management.' Management did
indeed first emerge in its present form
in large-scale business organizations. . . .
But we soon learned that management is needed
in all modern organizations. In fact, we,
soon learned that it is needed even more
in organizations that are not businesses,
whether not-for-profit but non-governmental
organizations (what in this book I propose
we call the 'social sector') or government
agencies. These organizations need management
the most precisely because they lack the
discipline of the 'bottom line' under which
business operates. That management is not
confined to business was recognized first
in the United States. But it is now becoming
accepted in every developed country.
We now know that
management is a generic function of all
organizations, whatever their specific mission.
It is the generic organ of the knowledge
society."
(p. 43)
Armand Mattelart,
Mapping World Communications (1991):
"These books
[by the business consultants and gurus]
which enjoyed a transnational readership
far broader than just business executives,
provided a medium for the followers of the
new business doctrine. . . .
'The field
of management,' wrote the sociologist Michel
Vilette in 1988, 'has contaminated all segments
of society and is perceived as a universal
cultural model.' Not only did the corporation
become a full actor in public life, expressing
itself more and more openly and acting politically
on all of society's problems, but its rules
of functioning, its scale of values, and
its ways of communicating all progressively
impregnated the whole body social. 'Managerial'
logic was instituted as the norm for managing
social relations."
(pp.
207-208)
The Impact of Business on Private Life
Juliet B.
Schor,
The Overworked American: The Unexpected
Decline of Leisure (New York: Basic,
1992)
in the period
from the late 60s to late 80s, the average
American employee added the equivalent
of an extra month of work per year and
lost 40 percent of leisure time)
Arlie Russell
Hochschild, The Time Bind: When Work
Becomes Home and Home Becomes Work (New
York: Henry Holt, 1997)
Witold
Rybczynski,
Waiting for the Weekend (New York:
Penguin, 1991)
Business as Culture
Tom Peters
and Robert H. Waterman, In Search of
Excellence (1982):
Perhaps culture
was taboo as a topic following William H.
Whyte, Jr.'s The Organization Man
and the conformist, gray flannel suit image
that he put forward. But what seems to have
been overlooked by Whyte, and management
theorists until recently, is what . . .
we call the "loose-tight" properties
of excellent companies. In the very same
institutions in which culture is so dominant,
the highest levels of true autonomy occur.
The culture regulates rigorously the few
variables that do count, and it provides
meaning. But within those qualitative values
(and in almost all other dimensions),
people are encouraged to stick out, to innovate.
(p. 105, from the section on "The Importance
of Culture")
Condition II Business is now perpetually
changing because of "global competition"
Joseph H.
Boyett and Henry P. Conn, Workplace 2000
(1992):
"Why are these changes occurring? Because
they have to occur. The 1980s taught some
bitter lessons to American business leaders.
Faced with accelerated global competition,
it became evident that . . .
America wasn't good enough. . . .
They were beating us because they tried
harder and expected morebetter quality,
better service, and faster innovation."
(p.
8)
Robert B. Reich,
The Work of Nations (1991):
"We
are living through a transformation that will
rearrange the politics and economics of the
coming century. There will be no national
products or technologies, no national corporations,
no national industries. There will no longer
be national economies. . . ."
(p. 3)
"The new organizational webs of high-value
enterprise, which are replacing the old core
pyramids of high-volume enterprise, are reaching
across the globe. Thus there is coming to
be no such organization as an 'American' (or
British or French or Japanese or West German)
corporation, nor any finished good called
an 'American' (or British or French or Japanese
or West German) product." (p. 110)
Condition III Business is changing
into the "postindustrial" (also
"Late-Capitalist")
Daniel Bell,
The Coming of Post-Industrial Society: A
Venture in Social Forecasting (New York:
Basic, 1973)
Alain Touraine,
The Post-Industrial Society, trans. L.
F. X. Mayhew (New York: Random House, 1971)
Alvin Toffler,
The Third Wave (New York: Bantam, 1981)
Fredric Jameson,
Postmodernism, or the Cultural Logic of Late
Capitalism (Durham: Duke Univ. Press, 1991)
Manuel Castells,
The Information Age: Economy, Society and
Culture, 3 vols. (Malden, Mass.: Blackwell,
1996-97)
The rise of knowledge work in the early and mid
20th century:
Shift from the original middle class (farmers,
craftsmen, small business owners) to the "new
middle class" (salaried managers and clerical
workers) (case study: business
in the 50s)
Shift from farming to manufacturing, and later
manufacturing to "service industries"
(also: the outsourcing of manufacturing to developing
countries)
"Knowledge work"
Peter Drucker,
Post-Capitalist Society (1993):
The basic
economic resource"the means
of production," to use the economist's
termis no longer capital, nor natural
resources (the economist's "land"),
nor "labor." It is and will
be knowledge. . . .
The leading social groups of the knowledge
society will be "knowledge workersknowledge
executives who know how to allocate knowledge
to productive use. . . .
Practically all these knowledge people
will be employed in organizations.
Knowledge is
now fast becoming the sole factor of production,
sidelining both capital and labor. It
may be premature (and certainly would
be presumptuous) to call ours a "knowledge
society"; so far, we have only a
knowledge economy. But our society is
surely "post-capitalist." (pp.
8, 20)
Peter
Senge, The Fifth Discipline: The
Art and Practice of the Learning Organization
(1990):
. . .
"learning organizations,"
organizations where people continually
expand their capacity to create the
results they truly desire, where new
and expansive patterns of thinking are
nurtured, where collective aspiration
is set free, and where people are continually
learning how to learn together. (p.
3)
To grasp
the meaning of "metanoia"
is to grasp the deeper meaning of "learning,"
for learning also involves a fundamental
shift or movement of mind. (p. 13)
William
H. Davidow and Michael S. Malone, The
Virtual Corporation (1992):
Throughout
most American history, the unwritten
definition of worker included
lack of education. (p. 187)
. . .
the process of becoming a virtual corporation,
before and after everything, is about
learning. . . . the virtual
corporation is a learning entity, struggling
to understand its mercurial operating
environment so as to successfully adapt
to it. (p. 194)
The virtual
corporation is a learning organization.
At any given moment it is a collection
of skills, talents, and experiences
that reside in the minds of its managers
and workers, and a body of information
relating to its products, its internal
structure, and its business relationships. . . .
(p. 203)
Joseph
H. Boyett and Henry P. Conn, Workplace
2000 (1992):
The world
itself is changing in respect to how
and what type of human effort is valued.
We are moving from a world in which
human value was derived from physical
prowess to one in which value is a function
of mental acuity. We are moving from
a world in which the strong not only
survived, but prospered, into one in
which the "philosopher," "thinker,"
"innovator," "creator,"
and "problem solver" is king.
Perhaps George Gilder, author of Microcosm:
The Quantum Revolution in Economics
and Technology, said it best when
he wrote: "The central event of
the 20th century is the overthrow of
matter. . . . "
(pp. 277-78)
"Pay for knowledge"/"Life Long
Learning""
Joseph
H. Boyett and Henry P. Conn, Workplace
2000 (1992):
In addition
to installing incentive pay as a substantial
portion of total compensation, many
companies will adopt a "pay-for-knowledge"
system. In these companies, workers
will have the opportunity to increase
their base pay by learning and maintaining
skills to perform multiple jobs within
the organization. (p. 6)
(II) Postindustrialism is Information
Technology
Information Tech Facilitates
Postindustrialism
Joseph H.
Boyett and Henry P. Conn, Workplace 2000
(1992):
In part, the
downsizing that occurred in the 1980s was
made possible by a new generation of technology
that is less expensive, more flexible, and
enables employees at the lowest level of
an organization to make critical decisions.
(p. 2)
. . .
success in the organization will flow to
those who can effectively use the data. . . .
Americans who want to succeed will need
the ability to analyze data, draw conclusions,
and present recommendations. Computer literacy
and at least a rudimentary knowledge of
statistics for business will be critical
for advancement or even to survive! (p.
5)
The ability of
large American companies to reconfigure
themselves to look and act like small businesses
can, at least in part, be attributed to
the development of new technology that makes
whole layers of managers and their staffs
unnecessary. Those layers (such as group
executives, corporate directors, and assistant
vice presidents) whose primary function
is to either filter information and, in
some cases, manipulate data being passed
up from lower levels or make routine decisions
will be particularly vulnerable to technology. . . .
In Workplace 2000, upper management
in practically every company will have the
technological tools not only to review company-wide
performance on a personal computer but to
tap directly into performance at the lowest
level. (p. 23)
Entire layers of management and supervision
will be erased from the organization chart.
Traditional ideas about a "span of
control" where a manager or supervisor
was needed for every four, five,or six employees
are being discarded. Instead of a narrow
span of control, companies are now beginning
to look at a much broader span of communication
or span of information as the basis for
establishing the number and levels of management.
(p. 28)
Information
Tech Represents Postindustrialism
The early "Productivity Paradox"
of IT
IT capital
and productivity in the
service sector. Data from
Stephen S. Roach, Technology
Imperatives; chart from
Thomas K. Landauer, The
Trouble with Computers,
p. 31
Thomas
K. Landauer, The Trouble
with Computers: Usefulness,
Usability, and Productivity
(Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press,
1995)
Stephen
S. Roach, Technology
Imperatives (New York: Morgan
Stanley, 1992)
Paul
A. Strassman, Information
Payoff: The Transformation of
Work in the Electronic Age
(New York: Free Press / Macmillan,
1985)
IT as symbolism, myth, and "spirit"
J.
Feldman and J. March,
"Information in Organizations
as Signal and Symbol" (1981):
"Using
information, asking for information,
and justifying decisions in terms
of information have all come to be
significant ways in which we symbolize
that [a] process is legitimate, that
we are good decision makers, and that
our organizations are well managed"
(p. 178)
Peter
Senge, The Fifth Discipline:
The Art and Practice of the Learning
Organization (1990): (pp. 13,
11)
Manuel
Castells, The Rise of Network
Society, vol. 1 of The Information
Age: Economy, Society and Culture
(Malden, Mass.: Blackwell, 1996-97):
"The
'spirit of informationalism' is the
culture of 'creative destruction'
accelerated to the speed of the optoelectronic
circuits that process its signals.
Schumpeter meets Weber in the cyberspace
of the network enterprise" (p.
199)
Business Week, Special Double
Issue on "The 21st Century Corporation"
with lead article titled "The Creative
Economy," 21-28 Aug. 2000
Manuel Castells, The Rise
of the Network Community, Vol. 1 of
The Information Age: Economy, Society
and Culture (Blackwell, 1996)
William H. Davidow and Michael S.
Malone, The Virtual Corporation:
Structuring and Revitalizing the Corporation
for the 21st Century (New York: HarperCollins,
1992)
Fredric Jameson, Postmodernism,
or the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism
(Durham: Duke Univ. Press, 1991)
Alan Liu, "Knowledge in the
Age of Knowledge Work," Profession
1999: 113-24
Armand Mattelart, Mapping World
Communications: War, Progress, Culture,
trans. Susan Emanuel and James A. Cohen
(Minneapolis: U. Minnesota Press, 1994)
[originally pub. as La Communication-monde.
Histoire des idées et des stratégies (Paris:
Editions La Découverte, 1991)]
John Micklethwait and Adrian Wooldridge,
The Witch Doctors: Making Sense of the
Management Game (New York: Times Books,
Random House, 1996)
Robert B. Reich, The Work
of Nations: Preparing Ourselves for 21st-Century
Capitalism (New York: Random House,
1992) [first pub. 1991; new Afterword in
1992]
Thomas A. Stewart, Intellectual
Capital: The New Wealth of Organizations
(New York: Doubleday, 1997)
Michel Vilette, L'homme qui croyait
au management (Paris: Seuil, 1988)
Restructuring,
Reengineering, and Downsizing
Michael Hammer & James Champy,
Reengineering the Corporation: A Manifesto
for Business Revolution (New York: Harper,
1993)
Robert M. Tomasko, Downsizing:
Reshaping the Corporation for the Future,
rev. ed. (New York: American Management
Assoc., 1990)
Team Work
Jon R. Katzenbach and Douglas K. Smith,
The Wisdom of Teams: Creating the High-Performance
Organization (New York: HarperBusiness,
1994) [first pub. 1993]
Mike Parker and Jane Slaughter,
Choosing Sides: Unions and the Team Concept
(Detroit: Labor Notes / South End Press,
1988)
Diversity
Management
Lee Gardenswartz and Anita Rowe,
Managing Diversity: A Complete Desk Reference
and Planning Guide (Burr Ridge, Illinois:
Irwin, 1993)
William B. Johnston and Arnold H. Packer,
Workforce 2000: Work and Workers for
the 21st Century, prepared for the U.
S. Department of Labor (Indianapolis, Indiana:
Hudson Institute, June 1987)
R. Roosevelt Thomas, Jr., Beyond
Race and Gender: Unleashing the Power of
Your Total Work Force by Managing Diversity
(New York: AMACOM, 1991)
Corporate
Culture
Terrence E. Deal and Allan A. Kennedy,
Corporate Cultures: The Rites and Rituals
of Corporate Life (Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley,
1982)
William G. Ouchi, Theory Z:
How American Business Can Meet the Japanese
Challenge (Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley,
1981)
Thomas J. [Tom] Peters and Robert H.
Waterman, In Search of Excellence:
Lessons from America's Best Run Companies
(New York: Harper and Row, 1982)
William Henry Leffingwell and Edwin
Marshall Robinson, Textbook of Office
Management, 2nd ed. (New York: McGraw-Hill,
1943)
Business in the Fifties
C. Wright Mills, White Collar:
The American Middle Classes (New York:
1951; rpt. Galaxy, 1956)
William H. Whyte, Jr., The Organization
Man (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1956)
The
Information Technology "Productivity Paradox,"
c. 1979-1995
Thomas K. Landauer, The Trouble
with Computers: Usefulness, Usability, and
Productivity (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT
Press, 1995)
Stephen S. Roach, Technology
Imperatives (New York: Morgan Stanley,
1992)
Paul A. Strassman, Information
Payoff: The Transformation of Work in the
Electronic Age (New York: Free Press
/ Macmillan, 1985)
Information as Symbolism
J. Feldman and J. March, "Information
in Organizations as Signal and Symbol"
(1981)
Andrew J. Flanagin
"Internet Use in the Contemporary
Media Environment," Human Communication
Research, 27 (2001): 153-81
"Social Pressures on Organizational
Website Adoption," Human Communication
Research 26 (2000): 618-646
Information Technology "Prophecies"
Michael
Dertouzos, What Will Be: How the
New World of Information Will Change Our
Lives (New York: Harper, 1998)
Bill
Gates, The Road Ahead, rev. ed.
(New York: Penguin, 1996)
The Increase
in Hours of Work
Juliet B. Schor, The Overworked
American: The Unexpected Decline of Leisure
(New York: HarperCollins, 1992)
Arlie Russell Hochschild, The
Time Bind: When Work Becomes Home and Home
Becomes Work (New York: Henry Holt,
1997):
In studying a paradigmatic business where
middle managers and others increasingly
give up home time for work time, Hochschild
observes: "In a cultural contest between
work and home . . . the workplace is winning."
Herbert S. Dordick and Georgette Wang,
The Information Society: A Retrospective
View (Newbury Park, Calif.: Sage, 1993)